Artificial Intelligence and Writing: A Modern-Day Frankenstein’s Monster

In 1818, Mary Shelley shared her chilling tale of Victor Frankenstein, a scientist whose ego-driven obsession to harness technology corrupted the creation of life, turning it into a soulless monstrosity reviled by his community. Now, nearly two centuries later, the fear of technology overshadowing and replacing human creativity looms over discussions on artificial intelligence (AI), particularly in storytelling and writing. Just as Shelley’s novel explored the perils of playing god, contemporary writers and readers alike grapple with the dangers of creating soulless stories through AI.

(Using AI to Develop and Workshop Your Characters.)

The idea of machines crafting narratives evokes images of mass-produced, soulless stories, devoid of the rich tapestry of human experience and expression. There is a palpable and legitimate concern that AI could become a modern-day Frankenstein’s monster, consuming the very essence of what makes storytelling—like any art—so profoundly human. Yet, it is crucial to distinguish between the reckless ambition that drove Victor Frankenstein and the emerging interactive, collaborative approach now possible to writers.

Loss of creativity through an automated standardization of manuscript production are imminent dangers AI presents for writers; a slippery slope of convenience and word quantity that allows one to churn out words designed to achieve the quantitative aspects of our craft while sacrificing the imaginative contributions storytelling brings to our audiences. Critics of artificial intelligence are spot-on in arguing that computer generations are devoid of human creativity. The contention that human imagination and intuition are sacrificed for ease and speed is critically important when introducing technological advances into any artistic realm, including storytelling.

The dire outcome of an increasing reliance on technology in writing is the eventual homogenization and predictability of stories. Plots, characters, and themes are replicated as formulas designed for maximum efficiency, turning these tools and skills of authors into bland and uninspired programs and scripts developed solely for replication to achieve predetermined goals. The essence of the journey and adventure for readers in a compelling manuscript is replaced by automatic generation and formulaic repetition to meet goals, disregarding the purpose of engaging in this craft to create an epic journey for our audiences.

Despite concerns about AI replacing human creativity, it can serve as a powerful tool to enhance the writing process. Technology can and should be harnessed to strike a delicate balance of assisting writers in storytelling while still preserving the creativity and imagination inherent in the craft. Word processors, spell-check, and the Internet have all brought innovations and ease to the craft of writing. Artificial intelligence can exist as another tool in the arsenal allowing writers to better express their thoughts, as long as we take care not to allow too much control of the process.

Imagine an artist with a palette of endless colors, countless hues representing possibilities and avenues for artistic expression. AI can offer writers a wealth of inspiration, analyzing vast amounts of ideas to suggest intriguing plot twists, character nuances, and narrative arcs. These suggestions are not meant to dictate the story but to spark the writer’s imagination, much like a muse whispering ideas that might otherwise remain undiscovered.

The benefits of artificial intelligence extend beyond mere inspiration. Consider the data-driven process of analyzing and quantifying feedback on an author’s manuscript, a method reminiscent of the soulless grades and reports we’ve all encountered, like readability scores and statistical evaluations. Responding to art with such mechanical analytics can feel equally soulless. Instead, technology can and should act as a translator turning mathematical calculations into understandable, useful feedback. Like an ancient oracle interpreting the will of the gods, AI tools can improve the storytelling process by transforming complex analytical and data-driven feedback into clear, actionable advice designed to be understood by writers, instead of a cold report written for statisticians. This transformation helps writers refine their craft without being overwhelmed by technical jargon and regression analysis.

Writing a novel is like exploring a labyrinth, where each turn and corridor unveils a new potential plot point, character development, or thematic element. It is easy to lose one’s way amidst the myriad details. AI-powered tools can act as an Ariadne’s thread, assisting writers in maintaining continuity and coherence throughout their narrative journey. No longer should an author forget that one of the characters went on vacation in Chapter Two, only to mysteriously appear later in the story to create a plot hole. Artificial intelligence can help authors by ensuring no crucial detail is forgotten, allowing them to weave believable and consistent stories with confidence and clarity.

It is vital to address a danger accessible to writers investigating the tools provided by artificial intelligence: It is obscene to use AI to churn out computer-written books. The heart of storytelling lies in the lived experiences, emotions, and perspectives that only a human can bring. The role of any tool used to support writers is not to create dry and stodgy drivel presented as stories but to empower them to tell their own, enriched by the tools we provide. AI should be a supportive partner, not a domineering presence flooding bookshelves with uninspired words.

With a growing catalog of instructional writing videos available instantly, we have writing instruction on everything from improving your craft to getting published and finding an audience. New videos are added every month!

In the spirit of Mary Shelley’s cautionary tale, writers need to recognize that AI is neither inherently good nor evil. It is a tool, and, like any tool, its impact depends on how it is used—or misused. When wielded with care and respect, AI can support and illuminate the path of creativity, making the process more efficient and enjoyable without compromising the integrity of the writer’s humanity and authentic voice. Abused or relied upon without thought to automate writing beyond its capabilities, artificial intelligence risks becoming the very monster we fear.

AI offers an exciting frontier for writers struggling to find ways to enhance their creative process. We should strive to harness this technology to support and augment human creativity, ensuring that the art of storytelling remains rich, diverse, and deeply human. By embracing it as a supporting partner instead of using it to produce a computer-generated end product, we can continue to craft stories that resonate with authenticity and emotional depth, preserving the irreplaceable essence of what it means to be a storyteller in an age of innovation.